Rss Feed
Tweeter button
Facebook button
Webonews button

To save the GOP health-care bill, think outside the box

The American Health Care Act is in trouble, with House Speaker Paul Ryan admitting Wednesday that the bill must change to make it through Congress. The reason? The GOP right and GOP center want different things, and the rules under which the proposed ObamaCare replacement can pass the Senate by a simple majority make it extremely hard to satisfy both sides.

But the apparently difficult problems of policy reforms are just that: “apparent.” With some outside-the-box thinking, some deal-making and a little humility, the AHCA can be saved.

The right wants to gut “essential benefits” rules that increase the cost of health care and to encourage interstate sale of insurance policies and tort reform to drive down the medical costs. The center is concerned with how the subsidies for health insurance are structured, and some senators are worried that their states will be hurt by the bill’s Medicaid revisions.

Let’s take these in reverse order. The Medicaid problem is a money problem, and here the Congressional Budget Office score helps. A portion of the billions in projected savings should be used to even out the states’ shares of Medicaid dollars. That’s just arithmetic.

Next, the tax credits can be fixed by changing how they’re calculated. Think of a square divided into four boxes: People are either poor or not poor, old or not old.

Under the current bill, the credits are weighted too much toward the “young and not poor.” Instead, the tax credits should be disproportionately aimed at the “poor and old” box and after that the “poor and young” box. Then perhaps some small slice of the credits can be for “the old and not poor” with none for “the young and not poor.”

The toughest puzzle: The GOP leadership says their demands cannot be addressed under “budget reconciliation,” the special process that allows bills to pass the Senate with a simple majority. To use this process, everything in the bill must affect the federal budget.

Republican leaders say that because tort reform, essential-benefits rules and interstate sales of insurance policies have nothing to do with taxes or spending, they cannot be included in the bill.

So use the taxing power to achieve those policy aims.

Want tort reform? Add an amendment imposing a mandatory monthly federal tax surcharge to every health-insurance policy in every state that doesn’t cap “pain and suffering” damages in medical-malpractice cases. (Even deep-blue states such as California have the caps.)

Want to slice and dice essential-benefit madness? Spell out the new baseline for essential benefits in an amendment and include a tax on every policy in every state deemed by Health and Human Services to mandate an overly costly set of essential benefits.

Want to encourage selling across state lines? Amend the health-care bill to include a tax surcharge on every health-insurance policy of every company that doesn’t offer at least one basic plan with the same coverage parameters in five states (while giving the HHS secretary the power to exempt genuine one-state companies). Incentivize companies to make a basic policy available broadly, and they’ll appear.

These proposals would use the taxing power and generate revenue, so the Senate parliamentarian would be hard-pressed to rule them out of order during reconciliation. With these provisions added to the bill, all sides’ major concerns are satisfied. Anything that’s left out could be addressed through regulations.

Republicans don’t have a lot of time to fix this bill, but the good news is that President Trump has done a lot of deals with many moving parts. Unlike President Barack Obama, he enjoys this process. By all accounts, Trump is going “full LBJ” on the AHCA. Great. Keep it up.

Convene the top three Republican leaders from both chambers and three of the most vocal critics from each chamber, as well. Put Vice President Mike Pence, Office of Management and Budget Director Mick Mulvaney, HHS Secretary Tom Price, White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus and chief strategist Stephen K. Bannon in the room.

The House Rules Committee can delay work on the bill while fixes are made, and the president can twist arms to ensure the changes make it through the House and to the Senate parliamentarian.

“No deal” is not an option. Failure now means a collapse, not of ObamaCare — though that will follow — but of the GOP majorities in Congress, even with the Senate Republicans’ lopsided 2018 advantage.

No golf for the president or the GOP congressional leadership now. No Easter recess either. They must deliver. All that’s required is a little humility from GOP lawmakers. That’s asking a lot, but they probably prefer a few moments of modesty to losing their jobs.

Special to The Washington Post

Article source:

Speak Your Mind